Failure Mode and Effects Analysis Application in External Beam Radiotherapy: a Systematic Review

Authors

  • Vedran Manestar Applied Radiotherapy Trinity (ARTT), School of Medicine, Trinity College Dublin, Ireland , University Hospital Centre Zagreb image/svg+xml Author
  • Anita O'Donovan Primijenjena radioterapija Trinity (ARTT), Medicinski fakultet, Trinity College Dublin, Irska Author
  • Sarah Barrett Primijenjena radioterapija Trinity (ARTT), Medicinski fakultet, Trinity College Dublin, Irska Author

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.55378/rv.48.1.3

Keywords:

Radiotherapy, FMEA, Risk analysis

Abstract

Background: Radiotherapy is a medical procedure with potential high risk to harm patients. In order to reduce that risk and create a workflow safe for patients, prospective analysis tools are used. Failure modes and effect analysis (FMEA) is one such tool, used to evaluate potential risks. As FMEA originated from industry, there is a constant effort to adjust FMEA methodology for use in radiotherapy. This has caused a variety of approaches and inhomogeneous practices.

Purpose: To investigate the current practice of FMEA in external beam radiotherapy and to propose a more standardised approach. Materials and Methods: The search was performed in PubMed, Ovid and Embase databases, resulting in 312 articles retrieved. Using PRISMA methodology the number of unique articles meeting inclusion and exclusion criteria was reduced to a total of 35, containing 38 analyses. The data on FMEA methodology implemented, scope of analysis, expert team composition, number of failure modes (FM) detected, relative priority number (RPN) threshold, number of FM exceeding the threshold, minimum, maximum and mean RPN, RPN calculation method and risk mitigation strategies were selected as important properties of FMEA.

Results: Data retrieved showed large variation in how FMEA is conducted. There is a considerable underreporting of minimum and mean RPN values. Large variations in RPN threshold value selection were also observed. Two different approaches to RPN calculation procedure were reported, and it is unclear what the best practice is. Expert teams were assembled according to the guidelines, but the optimal number of members is unclear. The vast majority of risk mitigation measures were applied directly, without the use of systematic tools.

Conclusion: FMEA is a well-established and widely used tool for prospective risk assessment in radiotherapy. As a result of this analysis, recommendations for more standardized approaches were proposed. Possible additional research goals were proposed in order to provide evidence for best practice in some areas of FMEA.

References

Huq, M.S., et al., The report of Task Group 100 of the AAPM: Application of risk analysis methods to radiation therapy quality management. Med Phys, 2016. 43(7): p. 4209-4262.

Rath, F., Tools for developing a quality management program: proactive tools (process mapping, value stream mapping, fault tree analysis, and failure mode and effects analysis). Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys, 2008. 71(1 Suppl): p. S187-90.

Liu, H.C., et al., Failure mode and effects analysis for proactive healthcare risk evaluation: A systematic literature review. J Eval Clin Pract, 2020. 26(4): p. 1320-1337.

Liu, H.C., et al., Risk evaluation approaches in failure mode and effects analysis: a literature overview. Expert Syst Appl. 2013. 40(2): p. 828-838.

Manger, R.P., et al., Failure mode and effects analysis and fault tree analysis of surface image guided cranial radiosurgery. Med Phys, 2015. 42(5): p. 2449-61.

Baehr, A., et al., Implementing a new scale for failure mode and effects analysis (FMEA) for risk analysis in a radiation oncology department. Strahlenther Onkol, 2020. 196(12): p. 1128-1134.

Rah, J.E., et al., A comparison of two prospective risk analysis methods: Traditional FMEA and a modified healthcare FMEA. Med Phys, 2016. 43(12): p. 6347-53.

Mancosu, P., et al., Critical Re-Evaluation of a Failure Mode Effect Analysis in a Radiation Therapy Department After 10 Years. Pract Radiat Oncol, 2021. 11(3): p. e329-e338.

Rah, J.E., et al., A comparison of two prospective risk analysis methods: Traditional FMEA and a modified healthcare FMEA. Med Phys, 2016. 43(12): p. 6347-53.

Klüter, S., et al., A practical implementation of risk management for the clinical introduction of online adaptive Magnetic Resonance-guided radiotherapy. Phys Imaging Radiat Oncol, 2021. 17: p. 53-57.

DeRosier, J., et al., Using health care Failure Mode and Effect Analysis: the VA National Center for Patient Safety’s prospective risk analysis system. Jt Comm J Qual Improv, 2002. 28(5): p. 248-67, 209

Vlayen A. Evaluation of time- and cost-saving modifications of HFMEA: an experimental approach in radiotherapy. J Patient Saf. 2011;7(3):165-8.

Mazeron, R., et al., Improving safety in radiotherapy: the implementation of the Global Risk Analysis method. Radiother Oncol, 2014. 112(2): p. 205-11.

Ford, E.C., et al., A streamlined failure mode and effects analysis. Med Phys, 2014. 41(6): p. 061709.

Ford, E.C., et al., Evaluation of safety in a radiation oncology setting using failure mode and effects analysis. International Journal of Radiation Oncology, Biology, Physics, 2009. 74(3): p. 852-8.

Page, M.J., et al., The PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. BMJ, 2021. 372: p. n71.

Frewen, H., et al., Failure mode and effects analysis in a paperless radiotherapy department. J Med Imaging Radiat Oncol, 2018. 62(5): p. 707-715.

Veronese, I., et al., Multi-institutional application of Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA) to CyberKnife Stereotactic Body Radiation Therapy (SBRT). Radiat Oncol, 2015. 10: p. 132.

Shen, J., et al., Evaluation and improvement the safety of total marrow irradiation with helical tomotherapy using repeat failure mode and effects analysis. Radiat Oncol, 2019. 14(1): p. 238.

Huq, M.S., et al., A method for evaluating quality assurance needs in radiation therapy. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys, 2008. 71(1 Suppl): p. S170-3.

Kisling, K., et al., A risk assessment of automated treatment planning and recommendations for clinical deployment. Med Phys, 2019. 46(6): p. 2567-2574.

Schuller, B., et al., Failure mode and effects analysis: A community practice perspective. International Journal of Radiation Oncology, 2016. 96(2): p. E541-E542.

Battirola Filho, J.C., et al., Process-aware FMEA framework for failure analysis in maintenance, Journal of Manufacturing Technology Management, 2017. 28(6): p. 822-848

Southard, P.B., et al., A modified Delphi methodology to conduct a failure modes effects analysis: a patient-centric effort in a clinical medical laboratory. Qual Manag Health Care, 2011. 20(2): p. 131-51.

Hauth, F., et al., Electronic Patient-Reported Outcome Measures in Radiation Oncology: Initial Experience After Workflow Implementation. JMIR Mhealth Uhealth, 2019. 7(7): p. e12345.

Gilmore, M.D.F. and C.G. Rowbottom, Evaluation of failure modes and effect analysis for routine risk assessment of lung radiotherapy at a UK center. J Appl Clin Med Phys, 2021. 22(5): p. 36-47.

Han, Y., et al., Impact of an electronic chart on the staff workload in a radiation oncology department. Jpn J Clin Oncol, 2005. 35(8): p. 470-4.

COVER Failure Mode and Effects Analysis Application in External Beam Radiotherapy: a Systematic Review

Downloads

Published

2024-05-08

Issue

Section

Review articles

Categories

How to Cite

Manestar, Vedran, Anita O'Donovan, and Sarah Barrett. 2024. “Failure Mode and Effects Analysis Application in External Beam Radiotherapy: A Systematic Review”. Radiological Journal 48 (1): 13-25. https://doi.org/10.55378/rv.48.1.3.

Similar Articles

1-10 of 38

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.

Most read articles by the same author(s)